DUMB vs SMART: A Strategic Guide to Church Facility Design

Imagine completing a building project only to discover your new facility doesn't actually enhance your ministry. Envision yourself leading a church in an older building designed for a completely different era and style of ministry. Your church is not a building, but your building impacts your church.

Since the 1980s, our team at Brown Church Development Group has partnered with churches of every size, style, and budget across the country—and after four decades, we’ve truly seen it all. Most of our work has not been with congregations sitting on unlimited budgets and building gleaming new campuses from scratch. Far more often, we’re invited into the situations we just described.

In countless consultations, we’ve spread out blueprints, walked hallways, and reviewed master plans drawn by well-meaning architects and leadership teams. Again and again, someone on our team will look at the layout and quietly remark, “Wow…that was a really dumb design.” Despite the best intentions, the spaces they created have unintentionally limited their ministry for years to come. A beautiful building that fails to help your ministry grow, will eventually become an expensive monument to the past.

When a church fails to design strategically, the results are frustrating and disappointing. We call these problem facilities DUMB—Disproportionate, Unclear, Misaligned, and Bloated. They may look impressive from the street, but inside they frustrate guests, drain resources, and stall growth.

What DUMB Looks Like

D - Disproportionate

The imbalance breaks the ministry.

In a DUMB facility, essential areas like worship space, relational space, children’s space, parking, and restrooms are completely out of sync. You might have 500 seats in the auditorium—but only enough children’s space for 10 kids and parking for 50 cars. This lack of balance between these spaces will lead to bottlenecks, pressure, and underutilized space. When churches are out of balance, they will always regress to their lowest common denominator.

U - Unclear

If people can’t find their way, they won’t find a reason to stay.

From entrances that are hidden or confusing, to wayfinding that feels like a maze, unclear design creates an instant disconnect—especially for first-time guests.

In DUMB buildings, signs don’t help, the layout makes no sense, and the path from parking to worship feels like an obstacle course. Instead of being welcomed in, people feel lost and unwelcome before the first hello.

The way people move through your church building shapes how they interact. Think about the journey of a newcomer, a family with children, or an elderly member. Is it clear how to get where they need to go?

M - Misaligned

When your space doesn’t reflect your culture.

Every church has a unique culture, calling, and vision. A misaligned building a different message than the church lives out. Maybe the design was copied from a megachurch in another city, or it reflects outdated models of ministry. Either way, it feels off.

Misalignment creates a tension between the people and the place—a disconnect that hinders community, worship, and mission.

B - Bloated

Big building. Big budget. Big regret.

In DUMB designs, more is never enough. There’s too much square footage, too little function, and way too many dollars spent on things that don’t actually advance the mission. These projects are overbuilt, over budget, and under-effective. Bloated buildings might impress for a moment, but they become a financial and operational burden that slows down ministry for years to come.

The SMART Facility Model

The danger of DUMB design isn’t merely inefficiency. It represents poor stewardship—Kingdom resources spent on walls that will not help ministry. Without a clear plan, churches can unintentionally build barriers that hinder ministry.

The good news is that these mistakes are avoidable. After decades of helping churches correct the problems of DUMB design, we created the SMART Facility Model—a ministry-first framework that strategically aligns your facility to fit your ministries future. SMART stands for Strategic, Measured, Accessible, Relational, and Timed. Each principle acts as a safeguard against costly missteps, ensuring that every square inch of space works for ministry rather than against it.

S - Strategic

Start with strategy, Not a wish list.

The first step in a SMART facility isn’t making a list of rooms you want—it’s clarifying your ministry strategy and how it will shape your space as you grow. Programs that work for a church of 100 may strain or collapse at 300+. Questions about multiple services, scalability of programs, and realistic budgets all impact facility needs. When you define where your ministry is headed, you can design a building that supports the future needs, not just today’s preferences.

M - Measured

Right-size all core ministry spaces.

Overbuilt churches waste money. Underbuilt churches limit growth. A SMART facility is designed with balanced capacities across core areas—worship seating, children’s ministry, parking, and lobbies all work together without bottlenecks or wasted space. We plan based on real ministry needs, not guesses or wish lists. That’s good stewardship.

A - Accessible

Intuitive paths of travel with proper adjacencies.

SMART churches are designed to make people feel welcome, safe, and at home. Whether it's a first-time guest or a longtime member, navigating the campus should be intuitive. Clear signage, logical layouts, ADA compliance, and thoughtful parking-to-pew pathways help people focus on worship—not on finding their way.

R - Relational

Buildings must bring people together.

Church isn’t just about providing a service, it’s about building a relationship vertically with God and horizontally to a community of believers. A SMART facility includes intentional spaces that help people connect: wide lobbies, commons areas, landing spots, and spaces that invite conversation. Relational spaces move people from rows to circles, from attending to belonging. In a SMART design, the building creates space for relationship.

T - Timed

Growth that’s guided by wisdom, not pressure.

Ministry grows in phases—and your building should too. SMART facilities are designed with scalable growth in mind, allowing you to build what you need now, while planning wisely for what comes next. Phased construction protects your resources and keeps your mission front and center. It’s about long-term vision, not short-term flash.

Conclusion

Your facility sets the tone for everything that happens within it. Choosing a SMART design is more than a construction decision; it’s an act of stewardship. A SMART facility utilizes every square foot as a ministry tool and planning for the people you haven’t reached yet. Strategy always comes before square footage. When you begin with a clear ministry strategy, the facilities designed will serve the next generation rather than becoming a burden they inherit.

The decisions you make now will shape ministry for decades. A SMART facility ensures that the story your building tells is one of growth and health—not of wasted resources and missed opportunities.

Start a Conversation Now!